Col 299-Sophomore Portfolio
PEER EDITING FEEDBACK SHEETS

Reflective Paper

Reflective Paper Writer: _____________________________________

Peer Editor: _____________________________________

I. Read the reflective paper, looking at spelling, grammar, sentence construction, general clarity of writing, etc. What needs to be improved?

II. Read the reflective paper for a second time
a. Are the thoughts well organized and the ideas logically developed? Please explain.

b. Does the paper communicate information about how well the author chose and learned from the activities and experiences? Please explain.

c. Does the paper demonstrate the author’s ability to think critically and independently? Please explain.

d. Does the paper communicate how the author has grown in knowledge, in the ability to think and evaluate, and in experience as a result of taking general education classes at SCC? Please explain.

e. Does the paper communicate how the author contributed to the class and interacted with other class members?

f. Any other suggestions for improvements?