Col 299-Sophomore Portfolio
PEER EDITING FEEDBACK SHEETS

Final Research Project

Research Paper Writer: _____________________________________

Peer Editor: _____________________________________

I. Read the research paper, looking at spelling, grammar, sentence construction, general clarity of writing, etc. What needs to be improved?

II. Read the research paper for a second time
a. Is the major thesis of the paper clear? Are the thoughts well organized and the ideas logically developed or is the argument confusing? Please explain.

b. Does the paper relate to one or more of the author’s journal entries?

c. Does the paper demonstrate critical thinking skills; include the author’s opinions, evaluation, analysis, and thoughts? Please give specific examples.

d. Are connections demonstrated between the author’s own ideas and the ideas collected from other sources? Please explain.

e. Is the annotated bibliography done correctly? Any suggestions for improvements?

f. Have formal style guidelines regarding in-text citations and documentation been done correctly? Suggest changes if needed.

g. Any other suggestions for improvements?